Difference Between Airplane Black Boxes And Car Black Boxes

Recent aviation disasters like the disappearance of flight MH370 highlight the importance of black boxes in aerospace communications. The question is what is the black box and is it similar to the one fitted in cars?

What is an Airplane Black Box?

Flight data recorder displayed at HAL Museum 7893

Credit: commons.wikimedia.org

Black boxes on airplanes provide such important information that other people or devices fail to provide. The box holds the story of what happened during the flight and what events occurred before the plane crashed.

Formally called flight data recorders, these black boxes record all the instructions sent to the electronic systems of the airplane. Recorded sounds include aerospace communications like conversations taking place in the cockpit, ambient sounds, performance parameters, radio communications, etc.

It can be said that the airplane’s black box acts like the eyewitness to events that led to the crash. It provides investigators helpful insight into what happened that caused the accident. In some cases, the black box might even give an explanation of why it occurred.

A black box points out safety lapses that can help find out who is responsible. Similarly, the answers it holds can also help ensure that a similar accident doesn’t occur in the future.

Learn more about (Telemetry and Aerospace Communications) here.

What is a car black box?

Crash Recorder vor Auto

Credit: commons.wikimedia.org

While it might come off as a surprise, your car might be fitted with its own version of a black box. If you recently bought a car, then there is a high chance that there is an event data recorder present on board. Since the device is installed out of sight, you can’t be sure if there is one or not. Moreover, car manufacturers also don’t clarify when it comes to the type of data being recorded.

Basically, a car black box comes fitted with a GPS unit which records when and where you drive to. Other features also include motion detectors and sensors that record how you are driving. The features also record the condition of the road you are driving on. Moreover, it will also check if you accelerate rapidly or push the brake suddenly.

Airplane Black Box vs. Car Black Box Comparison Chart

Following is a brief comparison of the technologies in an airplane black box and car black box

TechnologiesAirplane Black BoxCar Black Box
Transmits data in real timeNoYes
Records important driving/flight parametersYesYes
Motion sensorsYesYes
Records technical malfunctionYesYes
Sensors like vehicle speed sensor, throttle position sensorYesYes
Standalone deviceNoNo
Government standardYesNo
Sound recordersYesNo
Industry standardYesNo
Locator beaconYesNo
Smartphone compatibleNoYes

Airplane Black Box vs. Car Black Box: Key Differences Explanation

Both the black boxes differ in certain aspects. A few of them are discussed below:

Locator Beacon

Some car black boxes can send crash logs to a server or an app. This feature is particularly present in black boxes used for usage-based insurance. However, airplane black boxes don’t have such technology. Instead, it is designed to withstand highly intense impacts and bad crashes. Similarly, it can survive extremely cold and hot conditions.

On the other hand, the airplane black box does come with an underwater location beacon. This beacon is powered by a battery and is activated when the black box goes under water. Once submerged in water, the beacon starts to emit an acoustic signal. A receiver within 20,000 feet can pick up this frequency. The beacon is activated in both salt and fresh water and can emit signals for up to a month. Due to this feature, it is easy to locate the airplane black box.

Data Storage

In the case of a car crash, the black box generates a crash record that contains approximately five seconds of data. This crash record logs the intensity of the crash, brake application, engine speed, and vehicle speed. All the information helps to figure out how your car was being operated before a crash and during it.

In a flight data recorder, there is a wealth of data. It stores different information like switch activations, airflow noise, control movement, aural alarms, etc. All the information is stored on memory chips. The recorded data help determine the causes of the crash and what happened during it.

Bonus: Escort Passport 8500X50 Black Radar Detector Review

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.